Most Americans in Switzerland assume that a green card and a US passport are interchangeable for tax purposes. In daily filing life, that's almost true: while your green card is in force, the IRS treats you as a resident alien, you report worldwide income, and you're subject to FBAR and Form 8938 reporting. But there's one structural difference that matters enormously if you ever leave: as a green card holder, you can end US tax residency without renouncing citizenship, and the off switch, Form I-407, is simpler than most people expect. The problem is what that switch can trip on the way out.
The green card's tax reality: resident alien, worldwide income
Lawful permanent residents are resident aliens under US law. That means your US tax return includes your Swiss salary, your Swiss bank interest, your rental income anywhere in the world, just as it would for a citizen in Basel or Bern. You also carry the same reporting duties: FBAR for foreign financial accounts and Form 8938 for specified foreign assets.
You're also eligible for the same relief tools the IRS gives citizens, including the foreign earned income exclusion and the foreign tax credit. The trade-off between those two tools is a decision Swiss-based Americans face every year, and we walk through the math in our FEIE vs foreign tax credit guide for Switzerland.
The difference between you and a citizen, then, isn't in the filing year. It's in the exit.
The clean off switch citizens don't get: Form I-407
A US citizen who wants to end US tax residency has one real path: renounce citizenship, a formal, costly, irreversible act. As a green card holder, you have a simpler administrative option. You can voluntarily abandon your lawful permanent resident status by filing Form I-407, and the form itself carries no filing fee.
What I-407 does is end your green card status. Once the abandonment is processed, you are no longer a US resident alien, and your US tax obligations shift to the rules that apply to nonresidents. What I-407 does not do is erase the past, and it does not shield you from the expatriation rules if you qualify as a long-term resident.
The catch: the 8-of-15 long-term resident test
Here's the part most Swiss-based green card holders never see coming. If you've held the green card for at least 8 of the last 15 tax years, US law calls you a long-term resident. And a long-term resident who ends US residency faces the same expatriation tax as a renouncing citizen, even though you never held a US passport.
8 of 15
Tax years that make a green card holder a 'long-term resident', and put the exit tax on the table
This is the quiet trap
Spend a decade building a career in Switzerland, and the 8-of-15 threshold is already behind you. The exit tax can appear not because you renounced anything, but simply because your green card status ended.
Are you a covered expatriate? The three 2026 tests
Being a long-term resident doesn't automatically mean you owe exit tax. The tax only applies if you're also a 'covered expatriate' on your expatriation date. Under the IRS draft instructions for Form 8854 in 2026, you meet that definition if any of the following is true:
- Your average annual US income tax liability for the five years before expatriation exceeds $211,000 (up from $206,000 in 2025).
- Your net worth on the day you abandon the green card is $2 million or more (this threshold is not indexed for inflation).
- You fail to certify on Form 8854 that you have complied with all US federal tax obligations for the five years before expatriation.
- Average income tax over prior 5 years (2026)
- $211,000 (2025: $206,000)
- Net worth on expatriation date
- $2,000,000 (not indexed)
- Mark-to-market exclusion (2026)
- $910,000 (2025: $866,000)
- Compliance certification
- Required on Form 8854
The compliance test is the one people forget. You don't need a seven-figure tax bill to be a covered expatriate, a failure to certify five years of compliance with FBAR, Form 8938 and tax filing obligations is enough on its own.
If the exit tax applies: the mark-to-market moment
A covered expatriate is treated as if they sold all worldwide assets on the day before expatriation. The first $910,000 of net gain is excluded in 2026 (up from $866,000 in 2025); gains above that are taxed under the usual capital gain rates. The trap is that you're taxed on a deemed sale, no actual sale required.
The treaty tie-breaker that can backfire
The US-Switzerland tax treaty appears to offer a softer exit: if you're a Swiss resident under the tie-breaker rules, you may file Form 8833 to take the position that the treaty overrides your US residency. No I-407, no formal abandonment, just a treaty claim. It looks like relief.
Electing the treaty tie-breaker to be treated as a nonresident can also trigger the expatriation tax for a long-term resident.
In other words, the off ramp that looks gentle can be the very event that makes the exit tax bite. If you're a long-term resident, treating Form 8833 as a milder alternative to I-407 would be a costly misunderstanding.
Leaving mid-year? You'll likely file a dual-status return
When your green card status ends partway through a tax year, one return doesn't capture both halves. You'll generally file a dual-status return, Form 1040 for the resident portion of the year and Form 1040-NR for the nonresident portion after you leave. The practical mechanics, including the timing around your move, echo what we outline in our guide to your first partial tax year in Switzerland, though the trigger for a green card holder is different.
The constructive path for green card holders in Switzerland
Nothing here is a reason to panic, it's a reason to calculate. If you're not near the 8-of-15 threshold or the covered expatriate tests, the off switch may be straightforward. If you are a long-term resident with meaningful assets, the math changes and the timing of an exit deserves a plan, not a form.
The key is knowing which test applies to you before you file anything. For a deeper walk through covered expatriate rules, timing and the mechanics of the exit tax, see our detailed guide to the US exit tax for Americans in Switzerland.
Before you file I-407 or Form 8833
Whether the exit tax applies depends on your income history, net worth and compliance record. That's a personal calculation, not a general rule, get personal advice before you pull the trigger.
