You moved to Geneva for the job, kept a US credit card, and now the tax software asks a question you've never seen: physical presence test or bona fide residence test? Both are entry points to the same tax break, the foreign earned income exclusion (FEIE), which lets you exclude a portion of your Swiss wages from US federal income tax, but they measure you in very different ways. The physical presence test is a pure stopwatch: 330 full days outside the US in any 12-month stretch. The bona fide residence test is a lifestyle interview: did you genuinely make Switzerland your home for an entire tax year?
$132,900 (2026)
FEIE maximum per qualifying person. Married couples each claim separately, for up to $265,800 combined, per IRS Form 2555 instructions.
The tax home test: the gatekeeper both tests share
Before either test can help you, both require a foreign tax home. The IRS defines your tax home as your regular or principal place of business, for most of us, that's the country where you work. If you moved to Switzerland but your job, your clients, and your paycheck all remain firmly in the US, your tax home hasn't moved offshore. The FEIE vs Foreign Tax Credit: The Switzerland Decision Guide for Americans walks through what happens once you clear this hurdle.
Physical presence test: a 330-day stopwatch
This is the only FEIE door available in the year you arrive. It asks a simple arithmetic question: were you physically outside the United States for at least 330 full days during any consecutive 12-month period? You get to choose the 12-month window, it can start before you moved, while you're mid-move, or after you settle in, which means you can position it to capture the largest block of Swiss salary.
What counts as a full day?
- A full day is a 24-hour period running from midnight to midnight. A flight that lands in the US at 11pm costs you the entire day, no pro-rating.
- Time in international airspace or over international waters does not count as being outside the US.
- Days in the US break the count, so those long Christmas weeks in Ohio will reduce the number of qualifying foreign days you can count.
- Public holidays, weekends, and Swiss public holidays all count as foreign days as long as you're outside the US at midnight.
Pick the window that works
Because the 330-day requirement applies to any 12-month stretch, you can test several windows in your head. If you landed on September 1, a window from September 1 to August 31 might exclude more Swiss income than a calendar-year window. This flexibility matters most in your first partial year in Switzerland, when the bona fide residence test is still locked.
Bona fide residence test: the calendar-year commitment
The bona fide residence test (BFR) doesn't count days. It asks whether you were a genuine resident of Switzerland for an uninterrupted period that includes an entire tax year, for most people, January 1 through December 31. The IRS decides based on your intent and actions: where you live, where your family is, whether you pay Swiss taxes, how you're registered with Swiss authorities. Living abroad for twelve months does not by itself make you a bona fide resident.
BFR has a narrower doorway: it's available only to US citizens and to resident aliens who are nationals of a country with a US income tax treaty. A permanent residence permit helps your case, but the IRS weighs the totality of your life in Switzerland, not the color of your permit.
Facts that build a bona fide residence case
- Paying Swiss federal, cantonal, and municipal taxes on your employment income
- Maintaining a Swiss apartment or house, and transferring your family's life there
- Holding a Swiss residence permit and registering with the local commune
- Keeping Swiss bank accounts, Swiss health insurance, and Swiss memberships
Physical presence vs bona fide residence at a glance
- Definition
- PPT: 330 full days outside the US in any consecutive 12 months. BFR: Genuine Swiss residence for an uninterrupted period that includes an entire tax year.
- First partial year
- Only PPT works; BFR isn't available until you complete a full tax year in Switzerland.
- US travel tolerance
- PPT: limited by the 330-day count; each full day in the US counts against you. BFR: no day count, trips home don't undermine residency if the facts still show Switzerland is your home.
- Role of intent
- PPT: none, a pure counting test. BFR: central, the IRS judges your intent and actions.
Your first partial year in Switzerland: PPT is the starting point
If you arrived in Switzerland in the middle of a tax year, the bona fide residence test is simply not an option yet. You need a full calendar year of residence under your belt first. That's why the physical presence test is the practical tool for your first US filing as a Swiss resident. For a detailed walkthrough of that filing, Your First Partial Tax Year in Switzerland as a US Citizen is a good place to start.
The Swiss angle: why BFR often comes into its own after year one
Once you've spent a complete calendar year in Switzerland, the BFR test starts to fit your life better if you've built genuine roots: a Swiss work contract, Swiss social security deductions, a lease, children in local schools. Those are exactly the facts the IRS looks for. The test is noticeably more forgiving of US trips, because a two-week vacation in Florida doesn't erase a year of living in Lausanne. But the FEIE isn't the only lever in your US tax return, Swiss Cantonal Tax: Where You Live Decides FEIE vs Foreign Tax Credit shows how your canton's tax rate changes the choice.
Common FEIE mistakes to avoid
- Assuming a residence permit equals bona fide residence. It's evidence, not proof.
- Counting partial travel days. A short flight connection in the US can sink a 330-day window.
- Switching tests mid-year without running the numbers. Your earnings and foreign tax credits change the calculation.
- Forgetting the tax home test. Even with 340 foreign days, you fail if your tax home is still in the US.
The bottom line
The test you qualify for isn't a prize, it's a function of your move date and your travel calendar. In your first partial year, use the physical presence test. After a complete calendar year of Swiss life, the bona fide residence test can become far more convenient, and sometimes more valuable. The choice depends on your exact situation, including your salary level, your canton, and how often you fly home, so this is genuinely a place to get personal advice. Before you land, Moving to Switzerland as a US Citizen: The Pre-Departure Tax Checklist is worth reading.
A note on choice
Both tests ultimately exclude the same foreign earned income, and you can be eligible for both in later years. The right one is the one that fits your facts, not the one that sounds simpler. If you're unsure, get personal advice before you file Form 2555.
